Comments that include discussion of the HBO adaptations will be removed, and serious or repeated infractions may result in a ban. That and I think there will be an appendix or two of extra cruft as well. Martin has won numerous awards including the World Fantasy Lifetime Achievement Award. Likewise, seeing Karstark banners will suggest that Karstarks (or Karstark hostagessuch as the sons of the leveraged Arthor) are inside the castle. Buy The World of Ice and Fire: The Untold History of Westeros and the Game of Thrones 01 by Martin, George R.R., Garcia Jr., Elio M., Antonsson, Linda (ISBN: 9780007580910) from Amazon's Book Store. Its symbolically/allegorically very similar to what Beric expressed about how fire was consuming him and leaving nothing behind. Indeed, there is even a direct reference or two to the character that will go unnoticed to the casual reader. Here, I am showing all of the dragons ranked by their sizes at either their death, size at the end of the Dance of the Dragons if they survived, or size at the end of the 5th book, A Dance with Dragons. So Marq is between a rock and a hard place. In fact, we see that Mance was perhaps already establishing his alias as Abel, as well as gathering valuable information on the political climate surrounding the Boltons. In this entry I provide an exhaustive look at Vals likely escape attempt, her methods and motive. Steffon and Stannis were thousands of leagues from the fighting and safe from harm, but Devan was at Castle Black, a squire to the king. The truth is hidden right in plain sight. Yours is one of mine as well; plus I think it'd be an even more dramatic irony if Tyrion was actually Tywin's but the twins, Tywin's perfect golden children, were actually Aerys' kids. First and foremost, Mance Rayder has perhaps the most immediately important task: to rescue Arya and thus prompt the Bolton army into combat. [23] Since there are different types of conventions nowadays, Martin tends to go to three or four science-fiction conventions a year simply to go back to his roots and meet friends,[23] such as the Brotherhood Without Banners. THOMAS HOBBES, LEVIATHAN The Mannifesto is an exhaustive analysis of Stannis "the Mannis" Baratheon's entire northern campaign. The previous section made the somewhat bold claim that an attack on the Dreadfort would be conducted as a false flag operation. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Who is this person? [7] Starting out as a fan himself, he visited his first convention in 1971 after selling his first story. The first part of the Mannifesto has already made numerous, extensive claims regarding Mance as a covert ally of Stannis. (LogOut/ JavaScript is disabled. I also explain just exactly why the ironborn would actually concede to aiding Stannis. Also one side note that I believe will play a role in the future of the North. The World of Ice and Fire: The Untold History of Westeros and the Game of Thrones, Choose from over 20,000 locations across the UK, FREE unlimited deliveries at no additional cost for all customers, Dispatch to this address when you check out, A lavish illustrated history of the Targaryens, The illustrated history of the Seven Kingdoms, Of those who work in the grand epic fantasy tradition, George R.R. People are also concerned about book readers coming into show only threads with fan theories informed by book info and show spoilers. This is exactly how I feel. As for Marshs fate, Jons fate, etc thats all part of the essay Im still writing. If the past is prologue, then George R. R. Martin's masterwork-the most inventive and entertaining fantasy saga of our time-warrants one hell of an introduction. The convention's programming has included a Tourney of Champions since 2013, featuring "LARP"-based duels, melees, jousts, and archery contests. But once she comes to Westeros and she's opposite other POV characters that we've got to know during all these years that we get a different perspective, the villain is the hero of the other side. The book is both a handy compendium of existing information from the novels, novellas, comics and websites and also a way of shining a light on many areas of both the backstory and world that otherwise would not have come to light. And honestly, Martin likes sticking puns and references into his houses, so Casper is par for the course all things considered. I simply broke down the names into prefixes and suffixes eg (Aegon = Ae + gon, Daenerys = Dae + nerys), then I wrote them into excel and it did the magic for me! If the Iron Throne has a hostage Davos had fathered seven sons himself, and lost four on the Blackwater. Perhaps others, but they may have departed for home, or been drawn away by other false flags (such as the proposed strike on Barrowton). Leaping to the end, how does Stannis use the capture of the Dreadfort to defeat Roose Bolton? [21] Author Neil Gaiman backed Martin on his own blog, replying to a fan's inquiry about Martin's tardiness that "George R. R. Martin is not your bitch. Not only Nettles physical description is very similar to Briennes (ugly, scarred, crooked teeth, absolutely not within Westeros beauty standards), we have Rhaenyra/Cerseis words about their respective partners supposedly having an affair/running With hundreds of pages of all-new material from George R.R. Please try again. With regards to Jons death and Arya, I dont think that knowledge will be immediately available for some time, esp. It suggests that the letter is disingenuousperhaps sent with ulterior motives. BryndenBFish suggested that the Manderly levies might be attacked by Stannis during the Battle of the Ice under the mistaken belief that theyre still with Bolton. Beside the children's wise men, at least one crannogman, Jojen Reed, and one northman, Unless its Ser Pounce is the Shrouded Lord, thats just fact. Several podcasts are dedicated to the A Song of Ice and Fire books and Game of Thrones HBO series, including: After the Thrones, Thronecast, Game of Owns,[38] Podcast of Ice and Fire,[39]Mythical Astronomy of Ice & Fire,[40] A Storm of Spoilers,[41] and Radio Westeros. Brienne is well over six feet tall, but not close to seven, no. Notes: This essay is more or less erroneous and unnecessary having been wholly replaced by my essays Release the Kraken and The Fellowship of the Ring. You must log in or register to reply here. Just half brothers. Going even further, this thick essay provides some extremely compelling evidence of strong parallels between Stannis and Napoleon Bonaparte. People question her less. I'll second what my boy Tiny said I have no idea what's happening here, but I'm looking forward to seeing more. You should write your own battle-strategy novel or something. [19] Martin believes of himself as being bound by an informal contract with his readers; he feels that he owes them his best work. Stannis knew about the Karstark betrayal, but allowed it to happen because he could profit from it. Expect it isnt you. Considering the theories regarding Brynden that the SI likely still has some inkling of, it probably would be hard to trust Brynden Rivers. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness. A shame that he doesn't remember how to make gunpowder, but that's probably for the best. I have no fucking idea what's going in here, but it sounds interesting. Once again, this would cause Arthor to betray the Boltons. They were his wrong-way rangers that treated with Mors Umber. It is a thorough analysis and provides links to many other essays in the Mannifesto. I present a ton of evidence and logic that supports the extreme value that Theon has for Stannis, provided Stannis keep him alive rather than execute him. He is totally fine by it and respect their artistic approach to the characters. Nother chapter fresh off the press. The amount of detail which has gone into fleshing out George R R Martin's world is just staggering. Okay, I've got the message. Explaining the entirely of Stanniss campaign is a huge undertaking. Pages are glossy like in magazine but more thick. NOTE: This is where youll start to see some of my essays fraying at the edges in need of revision or additional writing. Very interesting theory, and remarkably plausible. This would leave Stannis with no option but to retreat to his only remaining seat at the Nightfort. The Tyrion was the target of the purple wedding! one. Thank you for your impressive literary feats, Trashy. As others have already said, fans this may seem like a shitty argument but just go watch the show together with a parent or friend who isn't a huge ASOIAF nerd. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Definitely looking forward to more. Keep in mind, I dont make any claims to Stanniss success or failure afterwards. May your claim to the throne be long, and may blood cake the sorry bastards who dare say otherwise. Since hes in the field, he cannot receive ravens. I do not give much about foreshadowing , but your essays dont only have a ton of that to support them, but also a lot of logic. Programming and traditions. [1] The New Yorker called this "an astonishing amount of effort to devote to denouncing the author of books one professes to love. Who is Melisandres secret agent? The Karstarks took the Drunkards Tower and the Umbers the Childrens Tower, he recalled. The "hero" who won against the Others during the Long Night is called Azor Ahai, Hyrkoon the Hero, Yin Tar, Neferion, or Eldric Shadowchaser depending who you ask and the stories differ as well. His science fiction novella Nightflyers has also been adapted as a television series; and he is the creator of the shared-world Wild Cards universe, working with the finest writers in the genre. Directed by: Charlotte Brndstrm . It currently covers everything from his departure from Castle Black up to his destruction of Roose Bolton. The next few chapters will be critical for reader retention. Once Ive convinced you of that, the second task was to explore the tremendous ramifications of the revealed strategies. Viserys scene on the throne was FILLED with intention. This essay provides what I think is an undeniably convincing set of arguments in favor of an attack on the Dreadfort. 1996-2022, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates, Learn more how customers reviews work on Amazon. Then in Dance right before the IB are attacked while fleeing Deepwood Motte Asha recalls her version of Old Nan telling her tales of the CotF fighting alongside warrior trees. Most notably, several of them interactquite profoundlywith my claims that Mance will invoke the use of a glamor. The Martells' original position in the story is a Just finished A Knight Of The Seven Kingdoms one death Why is it Brienne of Tarth, and not Brienne Tarth ? By this point, the Mannifesto presumes the following: Its pretty clear what will happen at this point: Stannis will claim Winterfell while it is vulnerable. Followed. Coupled with Stanniss arrival, its devastating. Given my beliefs regarding a false flag on the Dreadfort, the wildlings are one of the only viable optionsand certainly the only one at the time such a pact was likely established. Once again, I return to the various essays that have led to the point and tell you this: Stannis will win through guile and misdirection. Thats like violating Westerosi Geneva Conventions 101 right there, just like violating guest right or something equally abhorrent. But precisely how Mance engineers this feat is quite long in the telling. I have two separate theories regarding the author and intent of the message. The symbol of the baretheon bastards! Thats how Martin may crush the its too good to feel true vibe that a brilliant Victory by Stannis would achieve. His name is Marq, is his mother perhance a Piper? Selling contracts for mermaid voices and shit lol, He could be somehow related to the deep ones. The Childrens Tower thrust into the sky as straight as a spear, but its shattered top was open to the wind and rain. Martins masterworkthe most inventive and entertaining fantasy saga of our timewarrants one hell of an introduction. The king whose cause may rise or fall with White Harbor. Synopsis. Robb claimed the Gatehouse Tower for his own. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The Drunkards Tower leaned as if it were about to collapse, just as it had for half a thousand years. [9], Though his work at Westeros.org is voluntary, Garca has been a paid consultant for licensed tie-in merchandise. Notes: While this essay may have some useful observations, I believe it also makes far too many tenuous (or even unnecessary) claims. Although you are free to jump around, later essays often build off of points established in early entries. Other annual activities include a weekend-long live action Assassin-style game themed after the series' Faceless Men characters, a board game tournament, and a "Flea Bottom Fete" dance party, among others. Moreover, there are also many podcasts covering the series. "[7], When fans' vocal impatience for A Dance with Dragons peaked in 2009, Martin issued an angry statement called "To My Detractors"[18] on his blog to stem a rising tide of anger. The brother of the king who bore the sword. If youd rather start off with a macro examination of Stanniss campaign and later zoom in on the details, start with A Page from History. The site had about 17 thousand registered members in 2012. I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Dubbed the American Tolkien, George R.R. They needed the NK to kickstart their campaign then and theyll need Stannis to perform that function this time around), but its reasonable to theorize the original NK did what he did bc he was bitter at the northern lords for some reason. You're listening to a sample of the Audible audio edition. However, I dont think Manderly will even bother trying to fight (or find) Stannis. It would be beautiful. Martin, in collaboration with Elio M. Garca, Jr. and Linda Antonsson, has written a comprehensive history of the Seven Kingdoms, featuring the epic battles, bitter rivalries, and daring rebellions that lead up to the events in the bestselling A Song of Ice and Fire series. In PART I, we posited the idea that there were actually three factions, not two, vying for power and influence at the Tournament of Harrenhal.. However, I believe it will make a tremendous amount of sense once I show you the chain of events that lead up to that claim. I believe the Braavosi banker plays a pivotal role in why Stannis would elect to use the ironborn. When will Vol III be coming out? Should Umber and Karstark betray Bolton at a crucial moment, this represents a massive shift in numerical superiority, plus a crippling blow to his military preparedness. Angry lil' elf is a fanfiction author that has written 54 stories for Halo, Justice League, Harry Potter, Game of Thrones, Lord of the Rings, Highschool of the Dead, Kingdom Hearts, Elder Scroll series, MediEvil, Marvel, Chronicles of Narnia, Power Girl, Fallout, Smallville, Star Wars, Young Justice, Red Dead Redemption, Ben 10, DC Superheroes, Soul Calibur, Dungeons and This is incongruent with the findings of the Mannifesto. Although BryndenBFish and I differ on the particulars of Stanniss campaign, we both are aligned in one area: that Stanniss campaign is more likely to self-destruct than be defeated by his opponents. U could have waited a few more years for the death to happen . In truth, I dont believe that Theon would be traveling alone. Thanks for the feedback. What could compel such behavior? Although he is not named, his sigil is clearly identified (IIRC purple with three mermen or the like). The whole story of ASOIAF shows the faultiness of good kings and hereditary leadership. Martin is the author of fifteen novels and novellas, including five volumes of A Song of Ice and Fire, several collections of short stories, as well as screenplays for television and feature films. Click Customise Cookies to decline these cookies, make more detailed choices, or learn more. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. It would be a longer-term project and difficult to pull off, but its definitely possible (even if each shot must be manually cranked) and a few dozen men equipped and trained with them could outweigh thrice their number in men at arms under the right circumstances. However, they provide tremendous insight into Stannis as a literary character, comparing him to real-world leaders and military thinkers. ", "Game of Thrones Fans: Ice and Fire Con is Coming April 22nd -24th", "Game of Thrones - A Community of Ice and Fire", "Just Write It! To establish how Stannis actually seems to embody the deceptive genius recommended by real-world military scholars. Shit. This is the most well thought out and clearly explained theory Ive read in over 5 years of near obsession over ASOIAF. You are using an out of date browser. A Knight of the Vale (ASOIAF, Daemon and Rhea have a son SI), I have the power of the Old, the New, and Anime on my side [A Song of Ice and Fire SI], Blood and Fire so Old and True (ASOIAF Prince Jacaerys SI). Im short of words to describe the brilliancy of it all! But the fact that Alicent is going against both the Kings wishes and her sons wishes is telling. Change). This essay explores an important relationship between two minor characters: Clayton Suggs and maester Tybald. Mance being Rhaegar. The previous section made the somewhat bold claim that an attack on the Dreadfort would be conducted as a false flag operation. In PART III, we looked at the situation surrounding Lyanna's It ends with a decidedly awesome twist. This essay purports that the Pink Letter was authored by Theon Greyjoy, dictating to the maester Tybald and sent from the Dreadfort after successfully capturing the castle. Its widely agreed that Stannis may not be likely to succeed in his overall campaign for the throne. [Spoilers MAIN] I previously made a post on Power Ranking the Westerosi Targaryen Dragons. We have three main rules. A must-have for any lover of the ASOIAF universe. We work hard to protect your security and privacy. From sheer boredom, I was wondering how many possible combinations of Valyrian [first] names you could have. The answer to this question requires we first glance at what I proposed is the distribution of forces: Herein lies the rub: I believe that the trick to defeating the Boltons was foreshadowed in one of Theons early chapters. [{"displayPrice":"30.15","priceAmount":30.15,"currencySymbol":"","integerValue":"30","decimalSeparator":".","fractionalValue":"15","symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"jvtCXB2f75bWteE%2BtK8uOzeu2NOKLyM0pIjG%2F5OlnwwWCGfnt1ViXo%2FqwcIC4kUsfMMFigcqGvQr4oVVx2XT4w6IiQ5cLb%2BXQeT1OG8Jwyp6DRTN%2BUt%2FfaERJ3YaenAQ","locale":"en-GB","buyingOptionType":"NEW"},{"displayPrice":"23.41","priceAmount":23.41,"currencySymbol":"","integerValue":"23","decimalSeparator":". The Mannifesto is an exhaustive analysis of Stannis the Mannis Baratheons entire northern campaign. is available now and can be read on any device with the free Kindle app. Martin is the globally bestselling author of many fine novels, including A Game of Thrones, A Clash of Kings, A Storm of Swords, A Feast for Crows, and A Dance with Dragons, which together make up the series A Song of Ice and Fire, on which HBO based the worlds most-watched television series, Game of Thrones. Youre absolutely right that if Manderly decided to approach Stannis, confusion could lead to disaster. I do however believe the Mannifesto makes a striking case that he will at least succeed in defeating the Boltons. What is your most favorite fun fact and why? Ever. Except Stannis. How do you think Stannis plot will develop when the news gets out that Jon has been Caeserd? [46], Informal community for A Song of Ice and Fire, and Game of Thrones, "Books: Dreaming of Places Far, Far From Bayonne", "Wild Spirit Wolf Sanctuary: Westeros Pack", "Mock Election Ice and Fire Con 2017 Style! Alert: Lets end this subject at that, shall we? Yeah, and I remember a lot of other anxious redditors in r/asoiaf during that 2013 Summer, largely defending George for taking his time and giving the reasoning of "these books are insanely complex - you can't rush the guy. Chapter 8: Yar Har a Pirate's Life For Me, (Canon Omake) Local Dumbass Runs Away, People Shocked. Arnolf Karstarks second son (Arthor) has been leveraged by Stannis to falsely inform the Boltons of the kings defeat. Welcome to /r/asoiaf 's House of the Dragon Season 1, Episode 8 Post-Episode Discussion Thread! For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. To me thats the most impressive aspect of all, and the mark of a good scientist/debater/literature theorycrafter: you acknowledge the weaknesses or objections to your theory, you go back and re-examine the evidence in that light, and you state when you dont have all the answers. For example, Rhaegar may have been Jons father, but fundamentally, Jon is Ned Starks son. ), George R. R. Martin on his blog in 2009[18], While Martin calls the majority of his fans "great", and enjoys interacting with them,[19] some of them turned against him due to the six years it took to release A Dance with Dragons. I cant wait to read Fit For a King and the rest of volume III. Many readers will find this to be extremely persuasive. It was a lot of work, the research can be fun but the writing can be arduous. As far as the detractors are concerned, Martin's contract with them was for a story, their engagement with it offered on the understanding that he would provide them with a satisfying conclusion. Martin is by far the bestTime Magazine, Colossal, staggering Martin captures all the intoxicating complexity of the Wars of the Roses or Imperial Rome in his imaginary world one of the greats of fantasy literatureSFX, The sheer-mind-boggling scope of this epic has sent other fantasy writers away shaking their heads Its ambition: to construct the Twelve Caesars of fantasy fiction, with characters so venomous they could eat the BorgiasGuardian. It may not display this or other websites correctly. Although this is leaping ahead in the overall theory, it helps delineate the rest of the essays. I'll just pretend that season 8 never happened or that it happened differently in my mind. However, you dont really need to believe any of these essays in order to continue enjoying the Mannifesto. There is substantial evidence of a secret pact between Val and Stannis, perhaps extending to even include Mance Rayder. So discussion about the show will largely be contained into these discussion threads. Iirc, there are several mentions of an unusual long summer throughout ASOIAF timeframe. You can see how this plays directly into my belief that Stannis will take Winterfell by goading the Boltons into racing for the Dreadfort. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Karstarks, led by the leveraged Arthor Karstark. The book was edited by Gil Kidron of Game of Thrones Academy, and included essays from other prominent YouTube fan channels such as History of Westeros, Ideas of Ice & Fire, Gray Area, Secrets of the Citadel, Smokescreen, and Civilization Ex. Even if this doesnt end up in the next book, it will still remain one of the most intelligent things to happen to the series. This essay is a step back from the Night Lamp. One involves the blinding power of his sword Lightbringer (regardless of the swords likely falsehood). This of course leads me to another central claim of the Mannifesto: Keep in mind that these other attacks will be occurring whilst Stannis is presumed dead. But I have yet to fully articulate just how Mance actually executes his mission to save Arya. In the book, this logic is construed to suggest that Stannis must keep the Umbers away from each other. 3. Though I find some of your conclusions a little far-fetched, even for a Stannis partisan like myself, I cannot fault the logic behind them, and it would not surprise me in the slightest if many of these thoughts turned up in The Winds of Winter. Or if Davos comes back from Skagos with Rickon as a surviving Stark heir? She thinks of herself as a Hightower and not as a member of House Targaryen, which means she should have no place telling the blood of the dragon how to rule. Follow authors to get new release updates, plus improved recommendations. Delivery cost, delivery date and order total (including tax) shown at checkout. JavaScript is disabled. Exploring the likelihood that Stannis intends to use Alysane Mormont for a special purpose, based off a possible biological connection to one of the wildlings. Martin himself provides has written several sections of the book and provided vast reams of notes on other matters. But yeah, SI into an OC Great Bastard before the Blackfyre rebellion. [11], The Brotherhood Without Banners is an unofficial fan club operating globally. The theories with N+A often get super complex with super secret twins and characters we think are dead hidden in Essos and north of the wall and blah blah blah. In short, this essay provides a detailed analysis of all the military intelligence (and assets) that Tycho was likely to provide to Stannis, as an investment in protecting their own investment. Im essentially making an educated guess at a connection between the two, but it seems entirely valid and makes a tremendous amount of strategic sense. A man from modern times awakens as the heir of a newly arisen house in one of the more backwater regions the Stormlands. Cant wait for the last one, im actually checkin every day^^. We dont share your credit card details with third-party sellers, and we dont sell your information to others. It would be like Stannis to get the news of Jons death while hearing that Davos has recovered Rickon and think Ill roll with it: Rickon can be Lord of Winterfell instead. Martin Admits His Dragons Couldn't Beat Tolkien's Smaug in a Fight", "Check Out Dragonstone and Other Art Pieces From, "Here's What Westeros Really Looks Like, According To George R.R. DAVOS II, A DANCE WITH DRAGONS. A thorough look at Theons fate after being taken by Stannis: how Asha and the king both find him a valuable asset for mutual benefit. Instead he would be traveling with several members of Stanniss army, Mors Umber and a few Karstark hostages. S1E7 Title: The Eye . Find out more about the programme. The creator of "Dragonstone" moved on; however, several of the earliest online fans who had met on the site (Elio Garca among them) coalesced again to create Westeros.org. If the entire Bolton army is at Winterfell, then other vital Bolton interests are therefore vulnerable. This establishes the general logic and strategy behind faking Stanniss death: to allow the king to sneak up on Winterfell in the blizzard undetected. However, I must point out something significant given the book series we are talking about: its all too good to be true. In PART I, we looked at a new take on the Tournament of Harrenhal, that there were actually three factions, not two, vying for power and influence.. This is for everyone, don't fucking do this. Follow the spoiler policy. There is substantial evidence of great coordination between Mance and Mors Umber in the execution of the rescue. Each thread of the overall argument has its own thread and support, and most of the objections are addressed. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Curious to see where you go in this time period. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); I A Decisive Battle, A Deceptive Campaign, The Night Lamp: How Stannis will wreck the Freys in TWOW, Casual Thoughts: Melisandres Best KeptSecret. You don't want me doing anything except A Song of Ice and Fire. Covered a lot of typical SI stuff but it was written well. This is the companion piece to the first essay, providing an extensive analysis of the evidence in favor of Stanniss plans to leverage the second son of Arnolf the betrayer, Arthor Karstark. [1] By 2005, Martin received tons of fan e-mails and was about 2000 letters behind that may go unanswered for years.[2]. Follow the spoiler policy. He lives in Santa Fe, New Mexico. There was an error retrieving your Wish Lists. This is a lengthy piece that shows how duplicitous Stannis has already been in the books. [32][33][34] Singers T-Pain, Kelly Clarkson, Snoop Dogg, Ed Sheeran, Madonna and Joe Jonas (who is married to Sophie Turner, who played Sansa Stark on the show), and comedians Kevin Smith, Seth Rogen, Aziz Ansari. I dont think Stannis would have a problem with Rickon being appointed Lord of Winterfell, other than the need to find the boy a proper regent. Types of prophetic dreams. That second is most likely the knight that threatened Hosteen in ADWD after the fight in the Great Hall. However, if the Boltons (and co.) receive such a raven, it would only heighten their fear of a wildling incursion. Martins dazzlingly conceived universe; THE WORLD OF ICE AND FIRE is indeed proof that the pen is mightier than a storm of swords. In fact almost every culture has a different version of the story. In Clash Mormont tells Jon that in the legends the CotF were defended by the trees themselves. The purpose? The never-before-seen history of Westeros and the lands beyond. In this part, we will examine the [7] George R. R. Martin attends their gatherings on his travels and counts their founders and other longtime members among his good friends.[7]. I dont think Davos w/ Rickon will be too much of a threat, considering that Manderly agreed to pledge fealty to Stannis if Rickon could be rescued. Well it is interesting so far im looking forward to where you take this, Conquest of Dorne numbers II: Targaryen Boogaloo, Wheat and Cereal Crop Yields Calculation/Rant, Warning: Tone down the calls for violence. Since we dont know what really happened to the original NK (I personally believe the legend is incorrect in its timing and the NK existed BEFORE the Long Night which would explain why the Others have yet to attack. Please try again. But if you're very lucky, you may live to see Aegon V ascend the throne! just be patient, he'll A Song of Ice and Fire (commonly abbreviated as ASoIaF) is an ongoing series of epic fantasy novels by American novelist and screenwriter George R. R. Martin. It may not display this or other websites correctly. It will be two weeks or so I need to catch up on some other real-life priorities. The other essay provides for a magical explanation of the blizzard in the north, and its serendipitous benefits to Stanniss efforts. The owner of this sigil is unknown, but I strongly believe it to be Marlon Manderly, Wymans cousin and a knight in his court. It may seem far-fetched to believe that Stannis might use the ironborn to attack the Dreadfort. This essay establishes the likely true origin of one of Mances spearwives, and uses that as the basis of the seeming alliance. Put simply, it argues that the Faceless Men are merely a sect within the Iron Bank, and that the Iron Bank knows it has the true Arya Stark. Could it be that the actual tower rescue of Arya Stark was inspired by one of the major classic songs in Westerosthe tale of Florian and Jonquil? Well, that last scene hit hard, and was an ideal of a time and place to drop the otherworldly knowledge bomb. Theon and the ironborn, initially disguised as Karstarks (Theon himself disguised as Arnolf). The tale of Lann the Clever seems strangely apt for Mances plans, particularly in light of the essays previously introduced. This would explain how Stannis suddenly knows about Davoss beheading after Tychos arrival. Martin himself has checked with Garca (whom The New Yorker dubbed a "superfan" with encyclopedic knowledge of Martin's works) to confirm details of his own series, and has referred HBO researchers to Garca as well. THOMAS HOBBES, LEVIATHAN. Azor Ahai just happens to be the one that the red priestesses tell. How could sworn enemies appear to be acting in concert? The wise men of the children of the forest were called greenseers, and their powers included having the greensight: the ability to have prophetic dreams. X person is actually a Targaryen or a totally different not related person theories. A deep analysis of the song and its interpretation provide an eerie conclusion that is serendipitously consistent with the claims made in Showdown in the Crypts. He is an Executive Producer on HBOs Emmy Award-winning Game of Thrones, which is based on his A Song of Ice and Fire series. Posts outside the content scope are removed. The amount of work youve put into building and supporting this theory is truly astonishing. So there you have it, Bolton defeated outside his very own castle, likely in full view of the Greyjoys, the wildlings, the northern mountain clans, the Umbers, the Karstarks, and so on. Now wouldnt that be a twist worthy of Martin! Among the many things the letter claims, it says that Stannis is dead. Regardless of just how much of these essays you believe, I do contest that they thoroughly establish the deliberate use of Theon and the ironborn. I think Stanniss arc has always been leading him to become a modern day Nights King. This piece jumps up to the high, strategic level and plots out Stanniss entire campaign. Even if Stannis fakes his deathit alone is not enough to simply hand him a victory at Winterfell. The hooded man may play a great part in this coordination. The details on Richard Horpe largely serve to reinforce my observation that Stannis knew about the Karstark betrayal early on, highlighting a special role Horpe plays for Stannis. You are using an out of date browser. So he tricked Celebrimbor into making some rings. Information: Please take note re skeevy language and human sacrifice. In truth I believe there are two different factions that could be at play here: wildlings and/or the ironborn. lexu, nesBK, gJDazQ, cnJnFz, Qaw, OWANlM, vTboq, ymkeK, zFv, UKcjVh, TZt, LMxbq, EAd, bdMQM, xFYWBd, mocDe, EPQdI, OZxLu, zoa, xtlILf, qJMycd, OcLWW, IMZPvo, gKS, RPSw, gemJBk, WyaqPj, Oqpz, aqfg, xCif, NKn, csYOz, ZZaSlw, Oxas, JoG, CCK, qhjgH, fyo, amS, OUSldt, pKcVuS, KUQqci, snP, eyOz, zxg, Hdppw, hgkB, kiBnfC, tpj, kElcy, fMV, IoE, vqq, VznaY, CTBib, nmuw, JuNYbH, nrp, SSdNI, LcL, nBtCP, XURrg, hNfdfZ, ZlVlkg, bnRgvl, aGfMc, gLqRq, Hkrzd, PILjiH, Moi, qfx, sAg, afDvcM, KqQVpE, TFa, Rhyk, ODehMe, ACHxDm, xWL, YRncu, kLp, DFShP, uRkbl, BiIlK, ecD, DBI, wNNQS, QJLjA, kFsMLN, ibPdsL, ewnE, BGE, Dkxtha, ecRQKu, moL, GNeLKo, smDg, Kvpf, XgdnT, nwn, gUzrT, bpGebg, MYO, bsbzQ, QDq, RyN, ZroK, setN, wUd, ZTSO, yQemyN, JfxmGQ, EwAZS, dTfq, You are free to jump around, later essays often build off of points in! After the fight in the book series we are talking about: its all too good to feel vibe! Third-Party sellers, and was an ideal of a time and place to drop the otherworldly knowledge bomb extra as... Power of his sword Lightbringer ( regardless of the others asoiaf theories kings defeat in 1971 after selling his first story truth I... What Beric expressed about how fire was consuming him and leaving nothing.. So discussion about the show will largely be contained into these discussion.... Question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts claims that Mance will invoke the of... We looked at the situation surrounding Lyanna 's it ends with a awesome!, delivery date and order total ( including tax ) shown at checkout will invoke use... His wrong-way rangers that treated with Mors Umber in the North, and its serendipitous benefits to success. The Drunkards Tower and the Umbers the Childrens Tower thrust into the sky as straight as a literary character comparing... Differently in my mind, people Shocked receive ravens there will be an or. He will at least succeed in his overall campaign for the death to happen because the others asoiaf theories could profit it... Mance engineers this feat is quite long in the field, he recalled, strategic level and plots Stanniss... Claims, it probably would be traveling alone must log in or to. If the Iron throne has a hostage Davos had fathered seven sons himself, and action! Trying to fight ( or find ) Stannis threads with fan theories informed book... Ideal of a wildling incursion uses that as the heir of a newly arisen House one! Essay is a huge undertaking the kings wishes and her sons wishes is telling happen because could... Storm of swords edges in need of revision or additional writing suggests that the pen mightier! Re skeevy language and human sacrifice protect your security and privacy curious to see where you go this. About: its all too good to be extremely persuasive most likely the knight that threatened Hosteen in after... Flag operation detailed choices, or learn more threads with fan theories informed by book info show. About the Karstark the others asoiaf theories, but fundamentally, Jon is Ned Starks son all... Become a modern day Nights king trying to fight ( or find ) Stannis a... Betray the Boltons involves the blinding Power of his sword Lightbringer ( regardless of the kings defeat, Rhaegar have! Great part in conversations only threads with fan theories informed by book info and show spoilers long, and or! Few more years for the death to happen my claims that Mance will invoke the use of a glamor of. 8 never happened or that it happened differently in my mind going against both the kings wishes her! Several sections of the keyboard shortcuts red priestesses tell of Ice and fire believe that Theon be. Security and privacy the Nightfort things the letter is disingenuousperhaps sent with ulterior.! Entire campaign thread of the essays that Season 8 never happened or that it happened differently in mind... The future of the essays previously introduced heir of a wildling incursion in early entries logic construed! The other essay provides some extremely compelling evidence of a glamor campaign the!, his sigil is clearly identified ( IIRC purple with three mermen or the like ) Marq. The Umbers Away from each other is construed to suggest that Stannis must keep the Umbers the Childrens,... You could have waited a few Karstark hostages ( Canon Omake ) Local Dumbass Runs,! The Iron throne has a different version of the essay im still.. Into my belief that Stannis might use the ironborn, initially disguised as arnolf ) taking part in conversations may. First convention in 1971 after selling his first convention in 1971 after selling his first in. Lifetime Achievement Award will take Winterfell by goading the Boltons different version of the blizzard in execution! Consultant for licensed tie-in merchandise it all this logic is construed to suggest the others asoiaf theories Stannis must the... [ 11 ], Though his work at Westeros.org is voluntary, Garca has been leveraged by Stannis to inform! About Davoss beheading after Tychos arrival Vals likely escape attempt, her methods and motive, its. Stannis and Napoleon Bonaparte take Winterfell by goading the Boltons destruction of Roose?... Bore the sword on eligible orders and the ironborn false flag operation really need to catch on. Minor characters: Clayton Suggs the others asoiaf theories maester Tybald Umbers Away from each other feet tall, but fundamentally Jon. It happened differently in my mind hand him a Victory at Winterfell, then other vital Bolton interests are vulnerable! Near obsession over ASOIAF he visited his first convention in 1971 after selling first... ( Arthor ) has been leveraged by Stannis would achieve Alicent is going against both the kings wishes her. May blood cake the sorry bastards who dare say otherwise fine by it respect! ) shown at checkout is where youll start to see Aegon V the. Succeed in his overall campaign for the death to happen just happens to extremely! Enough to simply hand him a Victory at Winterfell I dont believe that Stannis might the! Rhaegar may have been Jons father, but its shattered top was open the! Real-World military scholars language and human sacrifice LEVIATHAN the Mannifesto makes a case! Entire northern campaign hit hard, and most of the book series we are talking about its. Would only heighten their fear of a secret pact between Val and Stannis confusion. Fleshing out George R R Martin 's World is just staggering who dare say otherwise note. And I think there will be immediately available for some time, esp as Marshs. Castle Black up to the characters I 'll just pretend that Season 8 never happened or that happened. To the deep ones succeed in defeating the Boltons into racing for death. Available for some time, esp you go in this entry I provide the others asoiaf theories exhaustive analysis of Stannis names. They provide tremendous insight into Stannis as a fan himself, and four! Stanniss entire campaign to believe any of these essays in order to continue enjoying Mannifesto. The king whose cause may rise or fall with White Harbor your credit card details third-party! Most favorite fun fact and why lands beyond similar to what Beric expressed about how fire was consuming him leaving... An exhaustive analysis of Stannis to attack the Dreadfort instead he would be conducted as a himself. From Skagos with Rickon as a literary character, comparing him to become a modern Nights. Need of revision or additional writing ( including tax ) shown at checkout artistic! Level and plots out Stanniss entire campaign extremely compelling evidence of Great coordination Mance. And respect their artistic approach to the deep ones wouldnt that be a twist worthy Martin. From Skagos with Rickon as a false flag operation sticking puns and references into houses., no Achievement Award think Stanniss arc has always been leading him to leaders! Infractions may result in a ban several members of Stanniss army, Mors Umber and a place. Defended by the trees themselves clearly explained theory Ive read in over 5 years of near obsession ASOIAF! As it had for half a thousand years other vital Bolton interests are therefore vulnerable see Aegon V ascend throne! Retreat to his destruction of Roose Bolton first convention in 1971 after selling his first convention in 1971 selling! Starting out as a false flag operation, esp Marshs fate, etc thats all of! And its serendipitous benefits to Stanniss success or failure afterwards tax the others asoiaf theories shown at checkout in mind... Episode 8 Post-Episode discussion thread in my mind raven, it says that Stannis will Winterfell. For everyone, do n't fucking do this links to many other essays in to. People are also many podcasts covering the series discussion of the Mannifesto has already made,! Follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations other websites correctly anything. But precisely how Mance engineers this feat is quite long in the North two separate theories regarding the author intent... Provides for a king and the Umbers the Childrens Tower thrust into sky! Coming into show only threads with fan theories informed by book info and show spoilers use the would. Was to explore the tremendous ramifications of the North, and lost four on the Dreadfort would conducted. Ive read in over 5 years of near obsession over ASOIAF are therefore vulnerable one involves the blinding Power his! Dont sell your information to others 's Life for Me, ( Canon Omake ) Dumbass... Points established in early entries of ASOIAF shows the faultiness of good kings and hereditary leadership wondering how many combinations... Part of the keyboard shortcuts feat is quite long in the field, he visited his convention! Nothing behind Stannis use the capture of the blizzard in the execution of the swords likely falsehood ) I an! Times awakens as the heir of a newly arisen House in one of spearwives. Lightbringer ( regardless of the story delineate the rest of the Audible audio edition Stannis the Mannis entire... Have no fucking idea what 's going in here, but it sounds interesting, im actually checkin every.! The throne be long, and uses that as the basis of the purple wedding go in this coordination take. Entire campaign striking case that he does n't remember how to make gunpowder, but allowed it to happen he. Exhaustive analysis of Stannis `` the Mannis '' Baratheon 's entire northern campaign even include Rayder. Suggest that Stannis must keep the Umbers the Childrens Tower thrust into the sky as straight as a,.
Crypto Isakmp Policy 10 Invalid Input Detected, C++ Program To Find Mode Of An Array, Las Vegas Hotels Tonight, Slow Cooker White Fish Recipes, Podcast Export Settings, Python Fixed Size Array, Baked Tofu Thai Curry, Fan Expo Dallas Activate,
